Skip to main content

COMMENTARY; “Experts” subjective and derogatory opinion


In a moment of euphoria, “experts” could become blind and lose their intellectuality and reasonableness leading them to express opinions devoid of common sense.

This was the case of many “experts” including Teuku Rezasyah, a researcher at the Indonesian Center of Democracy, Diplomacy and Defense who “are voicing concern that incoming chair Cambodia may not do as well and may not use the office neutrality to resolve its border dispute with Thailand,” as reported by Mustaqim Adamrah in the Jakarta Post, Jakarta on Wednesday 23 November 2011 under the title “Can Cambodia match Indonesia’s good job at ASEAN’s helm?” Mustaqim Adamrah also reported that Syamsul Hadi, University of Indonesia International Relations expert had said: “It will probably be hard for Cambodia not to use its chairmanship and to act as a fair chairman in border disputes with Thailand.”

Cambodians sincerely and proudly admire ASEAN for the job well done under Indonesia chair in 2011. Doing well or not by ASEAN under the chairmanship of Cambodia depends largely on the spirit of collaboration and trust among the member states, due to the fact and reality that the foundation insuring the success of ASEAN in 2012, namely ASEAN Charter, ASEAN and ASEAN Plus’ successive declarations, the secretariat general and other functioning offices, and the long running ASEAN agenda have remained undisturbed. Nine years ago, in 2002 through the process of annual rotation of chairmanship among ten member states, and it was just less than 4 years after the Kingdom of Cambodia achieved total peace, political stability and internal security under the win-win policy of Samdech Akka Moha Sena Padey Techo HUN SEN, Prime Minister, ASEAN was under the chairmanship of Cambodia and the success of ASEAN was acclaimed by all member states, regional and world participants. Therefore, the said “Experts” should not have short memory and should not have missed meaningful information in support of their opinion.

Samdech Techo HUN SEN, in receiving symbolically the ASEAN’s rotating chairmanship handed over by Indonesia last week in Bali has officially reconfirmed the Royal Government of Cambodia position by requesting Indonesia to continue its role as the representative of ASEAN to solve the border conflicts between Cambodia and Thailand under the framework of the International Court of Justice (ICJ). The Bangkok Post published an article on 22 November under the title “Thailand hands in border reports to ICJ” is fair enough to report the request expressed by Samdech Techo HUN SEN during a meeting with Indonesia’s President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono.

The “experts” including Teuku Rezasyah and Syamsul Hadi should not have missed this meaningful piece of information, and should not have expressed such a derogatory opinion doubting Cambodia’s qualification to uphold the chairmanship’s neutrality in Cambodia’s border dispute with Thailand. On the other hand it is extremely sad when those who call themselves “experts” work frantically to transform the chairmanship of ASEAN to be a contest for prestige among leaders of member nations. It is fully appropriate to remind those unworthy “experts” the motto of ASEAN, that is:  One vision, one identity, one community (Article 36 of ASEAN Charter)
25 November 2011

Press and Quick Reaction Unit
Office of the Council of Ministers
Royal Government of Cambodia

Popular posts from this blog

ប្រវត្តិរបស់មហាក្សត្រីអង្គមុី ឬអង្គមិញ ដែលយួនលើកបន្តប់ជាមហាក្សត្រីខ្មែរទី៩៧

ព្រះមហាក្សត្រីអង្គមីុ ឬ អង្គមេញ ទ្រង់ជាមហាក្សត្រីខ្មែរទី៩៧ នៃរាជាណាចក្រខ្មែរឧដុង្គ ទ្រង់គឺជាអ្នកមានអំណាចម្នាក់នៅក្នុងចំនោមស្ត្រីបីនាក់នៅសម័យនោះដែរ។ ព្រះនាងត្រូវបានវៀតណាមលើកឲ្យក្លាយជាព្រះមហាក្សត្រីខ្មែរ នៅក្នុងអំឡុងពេលដែលក្រុងកម្ពជាមានសង្រ្គាមជាមួយសៀម។ ព្រះនាង គឺជាសែលោហិតរាជវង្សនរោត្តម មិនតែប៉ុណ្ណោះទេទ្រង់មានឥសរយស្សជា សម្តេចសិល្បៈករប្រចាំក្រុងកម្ពុជានាសម័យនោះ ព្រះអង្គឡើងគ្រោងរាជចាប់ពីឆ្នាំ (១៨៣៥-១៨៤១) ព្រះអង្គសោយរាជ្យបានរយៈពេល៦ឆ្នាំ។ ព្រះអង្គឡើងសោយរាជ្យបន្តពីព្រះបាទឧទ័យរាជា (ព្រះ បាទឧទ័យរាជា ជាទទៅនៅសម័យនោះគេហៅព្រអង្គថាអង្គច័ន្ទ) ទ្រង់ឡើងសោយរាជ្យបន្តពីបិតារបស់ព្រះអង្គ គឺព្រះអង្គអេង។ នៅរាជសម័យបន្ទាប់ពីព្រះមហាក្សត្រីអង្គមុី គឺព្រះបាទហរិរះរាមាឥសារាធិបតី ដែលយើងស្គាល់គ្រប់គ្នាគឺ ព្រះបាទអង្គឌួង ព្រះអង្គប្រសូត្រនៅឆ្នាំ១៧៩៦ ហើយសោយទីវង្គត់ នៅខែតុលា ឆ្នាំ ១៨៦០ ក្នុងព្រះជន ៦៤ព្រះវវស្សា ព្រះអង្គគឺជាក្សត្រមួយអង្គដែលបានសង្រ្គោះកម្ពុជាពីកន្តាប់ដៃសៀមនឹងវៀតណាម។ ព្រះអង្គឡើងសោយរាជចាប់ពីឆ្នាំ ១៨៤៧ ដល់ ១៨៦០។  ព្រះមហាក្សត្រីអង្គមីុ សោយទិវង្គត់នៅ ក្នុងខែធ្នូ ឆ្នាំ១៨៧៤ ក្នុងព្រះជន្មាយុ ៥៩ ព្រះវវស្សា ក្ន...

សារ​លិខិត​រំលែក​ទុក្ខ​របស់ ឯកឧត្តម Kim Sung-Hwan រដ្ឋមន្រ្តី​ការ​បរទេស​នៃ​សាធារ​ណ​រដ្ឋកូរ៉េ ជូន សមេ្តច​អគ្គម​ហាសេនា​បតីតេជោ ហ៊ុន សែន នាយករដ្ឋមន្ត្រី នៃព្រះ​រាជា​ណាច​ក្រកម្ពុជា

Cambodia and Japan commit to preserve heritage site as oil and gas exploration begins in Preah Vihear

PHNOM PENH, Jan. 30, 2012 – The Japanese Oil, Gas and Metals National Corporation (JOGMEC) agreed with Cambodian Deputy Prime Minister Dr. Sok An in a meeting on Monday that the historic temples of Preah Vihear province must be protected and conserved. H.E. Dr. Sok An, Minister in Charge of the Office of the Council of Ministers, told Akira Suzuki, Executive Director and member of the Board of JOGMEC, that there are more than 200 historic sites in the province, including the Temple of Preah Vihear. Dr. Sok An said that it is very important that such cultural heritage be cared for so as to attract more tourists to the area. Already there are 2,000 tourists per day visiting Preah Vihear province. The province is also rich in mineral resources and fertile land for agriculture, he said. The area is also a home of an endangered bird that is attractive to tourists. “If we can discover oil and gas, that is a very good asset for Preah Vihear province and for Cambodia as a w...

រាយនាមព្រះមហាក្សត្រខ្មែរ និងរាជសម័យនៃការគ្រប់គ្រងប្រទេស

ការសិក្សាស្រាវជ្រាវអំពីប្រវត្តិសាស្ត្រ​ខ្មែរ មិនមែនជារឿងងាយទេ ដោយសារតែគ្មានឯកសារច្បាស់លាស់បន្សល់ទុក​ឱ្យស្រាវជ្រាវ។ ដូច្នេះយើងត្រូវតែកកាយរើមួយម្តងមួយផ្នែកៗ មករៀបចំផ្គុំគ្នាដើម្បីឱ្យបានឃើញការពិតពីមួយសម័យកាលទៅមួយសម័យទៀត។ ខាងក្រោមនេះ គឺជាការស្រាវជ្រាវប្រវត្តិនៃការគ្រប់គ្រងរបស់ព្រះមហាក្សត្រខ្មែរ និងព្រះនាមរបស់ទ្រង់នីមួយៗ៖ * សម័យនគរភ្នំ (ហ្វូណន សវទី១ ៥៥០ គស) 1. ព្រះនាងសោមាហៅលីវយី (ដើមសតវត្សទី១) 2. កៅណ្ឌិន្យ(៦៨) 3. មិនស្គាល់ព្រះនាម (សតវត្សទី២) 4. មិនស្គាល់ព្រះនាម ចិនហៅ បាន់ ហួង (សតវត្សទី២) 5. មិនស្គាល់ព្រះនាម ចិនហៅ ហ្វាន់ហ្វាន់(ដើមសតវត្សទី៣) 6. ស្រីម៉ារ៉ា ចិនហៅ ចេម៉ាន់(២០៥- ២២៥) 7. មិនស្គាល់ព្រះនាមចិនហៅ Fan chin sheng(២២៥) 8. មិនស្គាល់ព្រះនាម ចិនហៅហ្វាន់ចាន់(២២៥ -២៤០) 9. មិនស្គាល់ព្រះនាម ចិនហៅហ្វាន់សីុយន់(២៤០- ២៨៧) 10. មិនស្គាល់ព្រះនាម(សតវត្សទី៣ ) 11. មិនស្គាល់ព្រះនាមចិនហៅតៀនជូ ចាន់តាន(សតវត្សទី៤) 12. មិនស្គាល់ព្រះនាម(សតវត្សទី៤ ) 13. កៅណ្ឌិន្យទី២ចិនហៅចាវចិនជូ( ? ៤៣៤) 14. ស្រី =ន្រ្ទវរ្ម័ន(៤៣៤- ៤៣៥) 15. មិនស្គាល់ព្រះនាម មិនស្គាល់រជ្ជកាល 16. មិនស្គាល់ព្រះនាម មិនស្គាល់រជ្ជកាល 17. កៅណ្ឌិន្យ...

Cambodia and Malaysia look to further cooperation in agriculture, tourism and education sectors

PHNOM PENH, February 20, 2014  – Cambodian Deputy Prime Minister Sok An and Malaysian Deputy Prime Minister shared views on Thursday that both countries can tap mutual benefits and complement each other. Malaysian Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Education Tan Sri Muhyiddin informed H.E. Sok An that, “Malaysia is good at rubber plantations, palm oil, and technology and the key is how best to work with Cambodia.” He said that Malaysian companies are interested in investing in processing rubber resin and can make good furniture from old rubber trees in Cambodia. Malaysian state run companies can also explore energy, generation, hydro-power plants and infrastructures such as roads in Cambodia. “We need feasibility studies first before the next steps can be taken. We can provide resources under the plan of privatization,” H.E. Tan Sri Muhyiddin said in the meeting. In response, H.E. Dr. Sok An, also Minister in charge of the Office of the Council of Minist...